Should You Choose the Cheapest Roofing Contractor or the Best One?

When it’s time to repair or replace your roof, especially after a storm or weather-related damage, many homeowners face a tough decision – should you go with the lowest bid, or invest in a quality roofing contractor? While choosing the cheapest option might seem like a smart way to save money upfront, it often ends up costing far more in the long run.

The truth is, roofing isn’t a commodity where all services are equal. A low bid often signals cost-cutting—either in the materials used, the qualifications of the crew, or the overall workmanship. Cheaper contractors may use subpar shingles or fail to install proper underlayment, flashing, or ventilation systems, leading to issues like leaks, mold, and early deterioration. In many cases, the work isn’t backed by a warranty, and the company might not even be licensed or insured—leaving homeowners unprotected if something goes wrong.

In contrast, choosing a certified, reputable roofing contractor provides long-term value and protection. A quality roofer brings experience, training, and insurance knowledge to the table. At Panthers Construction, we’re HAAG certified, fully insured, and experienced in working directly with your insurance company. This means we don’t just fix roofs, we help our clients navigate the insurance claims process, ensuring you get the coverage and restoration you’re entitled to.

If your roofing project is insurance-related, this partnership becomes even more critical. Insurance companies expect professional damage documentation, accurate scopes of work, and fair pricing based. A cheap contractor who lacks this knowledge can actually jeopardize your claim, or leave you paying more out of pocket. We advocate for our clients from start to finish to make sure you get the quality you’re paying for and the protection you deserve.

Many homeowners are understandably cautious about roofing contractors, especially after a storm when “storm chasers” show up offering deals that seem too good to be true. Some common red flags to watch for include vague proposals, no local references, high-pressure sales tactics, or asking for large upfront payments. These warning signs often accompany poor workmanship and companies that disappear once the job is done.

At Panthers Construction, we pride ourselves on being different. We’re not the cheapest and we don’t aim to be. Instead, we offer something more valuable – peace of mind. From helping you file your claim and meeting with your adjuster to installing a Panther-Strong roof that’s built to last, we deliver quality every step of the way. Our team stands by our work with warranties and a commitment to excellence that’s earned us the trust of homeowners across Central Indiana.

So, if you’ve recently received a roofing estimate and you’re unsure whether to choose the lowest bid or the best value, we invite you to get a second opinion. Our team will review your quote, inspect your roof at no cost, and give you honest feedback so you can make an informed decision, one that protects your home and your investment.